Serendip is an independent site partnering with faculty at multiple colleges and universities around the world. Happy exploring!

One Student's picture

genres of gay (male) narrative; and the genre(?) of fanfiction

In the first chapter ('History') of Neil Bartlett's Who Was That Man? (a bio of Oscar Wilde), Bartlett describes three forms of gay narrative, three genres:

1) The personal coming out story.

2) The history of homosexuality.

3) And one which "combines the historical methods of the second with the individual subject of the first. The hero in this case is a single, usually 'great' homosexual. His fame rests in part on being hidden, on being in need of revelation ..."

Reading Notes from "Genre and Gender"


Reading Notes from Mary Eagleton,
"Genre and Gender"

feminist criticism looks at genre in terms of sexual difference
and asks if we can create a criticism which is non-essentialist and non-reductive...

the novel became a possible form for women; lyricism was too assertive/egotistic
literary history privileges male-cominated forms; female forms were seen as less literary
generic divisions are not neutral , impartial; aesthetic judgements are ideologically bound

Reading Notes on Derrida, "The Law of Genre"

Reading Notes on Derrida, "The Law of Genre"

 

"Genres are not to be mixed": a limit is drawn, norms and interdictions...


"As soon as genre announces itself, one must respect a norm...one must not risk impurity."

One Student's picture

life and art on the same side of the mirror

I have felt very grudging toward usages of 'genre' which expand the word beyond a strictly literary term. Of course humans categorize all aspects of their existence, and there's no need to take terms from one categoried area and apply it to another. That increases the sloppiness of categorization, by using an unneeded metaphor. 

One Student's picture

the anatomy of genre

And another thing:

Genre is not the same as structure. Genres usually have a structure, though there is a certain amount of malleability in the structure for the particular works in a given genre: less for a sonnet than a novel, more for a comedy than a tragedy (and at one point does something stop being a novel and become something else which is novel-like? Difficult.) What distinguishes structure from genre? Do particular genres have a particular kind of content? No. What is there to a piece of writing besides structure and content?

One Student's picture

farther to endward

Ok, got bogged down last time.

My overall topic is: how does humor function in Uncle Tom's Cabin? I'm not theorizing on the difference between characters in comedies and characters with comedic attributes in serious works. 

One principle of the theory of humor which I am constructing is that a work may be humorous in nature, or a work may be non-humorous ('serious', is too value-laden a term) but with comedic elements. (Likewise, there are tragic works and tragic elements in non-tragic works; adventure stories can have tragic and comedic elements without being either comic or tragic overall).

One Student's picture

endward, or not

So, I'm reading "Get Out of Gaol Free, or: How to Read a Comic Plot" by John Bruns (Journal of Narrative Theory, v.35 no.1, Winter 2005, pg. 25-60).

Science and Public Responsibility

The Need for a Science Code of Conduct?

These evolving materials are provided to encourage continuing and new thought about science and its role in culture and, in particular, about the possible need of both scientists and others to clarify the ethical responsibilities inherent in scientific research. Your thoughts are welcome in the on-line forum area below.

Syndicate content